1958
| Played | Won | Lost | Draws | For | Against | Points | Position |
| 18 | 11 | 6 | 1 | 291 | 251 | 23 | 3rd out of 10 |
| Round 1 | Manly 21 vs St.George 15 | Sydney Cricket Ground |
| Round 2 | Balmain 21 vs Manly 15 | Sydney Cricket Ground |
| Round 3 | Manly 41 vs Parramatta 14 | Brookvale |
| Round 4 | Manly 12 vs Newtown 7 | Sydney Cricket Ground |
| Round 5 | Manly 45 vs South Sydney 16 | Brookvale |
| Round 6 | Manly 21 vs Western Suburbs 20 | Brookvale |
| Round 7 | Eastern Suburbs 26 vs Manly 7 | Sydney Sports Ground |
| Round 8 | Canterbury 8 vs Manly 8 | Brookvale |
| Round 9 | Manly 7 vs North Sydney 12 | North Sydney Oval |
| Round 10 | Manly 7 vs St.George 24 | Kogarah |
| Round 11 | Balmain 0 vs Manly 19 | Brookvale |
| Round 12 | Manly 21 vs Parramatta 9 | Cumberland |
| Round 13 | Manly 9 vs Newtown 17 | Brookvale |
| Round 14 | Manly 17 vs South Sydney 10 | Redfern |
| Round 15 | Manly 7 vs Western Suburbs 34 | Sydney Cricket Ground |
| Round 16 | Eastern Suburbs 6 vs Manly 12 | Brookvale |
| Round 17 | Canterbury 10 vs Manly 15 | Belmore |
| Round 18 | Manly 7 vs North Sydney 2 | Brookvale |
